Back
Top 5 Mistakes Companies Make with Helpdesk Automation (and How to Avoid Them)
Benny
- April 21, 2025
4 min read
Automation is the secret sauce for scaling support operations, improving response times, and keeping agents sane.
But let’s face it—when not done right, it can lead to more chaos than clarity.
At Saasly, we've seen companies automate their helpdesk into a state of elegant efficiency... and others who’ve built themselves an automated mess of epic proportions.
If you've ever set an auto-responder that sent the same apology email 97 times or escalated a ticket to a sleeping agent on leave, this one's for you.
Here are the top 5 mistakes companies make when automating their helpdesk (and yes, we’ll tell you how to fix them too).
1. Automating Without a Clear Strategy
Mistake: Companies jump into automation because "everyone is doing it."
So they automate everything without understanding why they’re doing it or what outcome they want.
Result? Disjointed workflows, confused agents, and customers getting auto-closed tickets before anyone even reads them.
Fix it:
- Start with a problem, not a tool. Are you getting too many repeat tickets? Are agents spending hours on password resets?
- Automate only what makes sense. Use Freshdesk’s automation rules or apps like Auto Close, Schedule Send, or Ticket Reopen to target specific pain points.
- Regularly review and refine.
2. Over-Automating the Human Touch
Mistake: Automation is amazing—until it starts replacing empathy.
Auto-replies, canned responses, and bots should assist, not replace, real conversations.
Result? Your customers feel like they’re yelling into a void of polite robotic apologies.
Fix it:
- Use tools like Followup Replies to re-engage inactive customers without spamming them.
- Introduce checkpoints where a human takes over.
- Use CSAT data to measure sentiment and tweak your automations accordingly.
3. Neglecting to Train Agents on Automation Logic
Mistake: Agents have no idea why a ticket was closed, tagged, or escalated—because automation is doing it all behind the scenes.
Result? Agents get confused, customers get inconsistent experiences, and nobody trusts the system.
Fix it:
- Document automation rules clearly.
- Involve your agents in the logic building process.
- Create agent-focused dashboards or notes using apps like Bookmark Tickets to help them stay informed.
4. No Fail-Safes or Escalation Triggers
Mistake: Automation is assumed to work 100% of the time. No backup plan, no monitoring, no escalation for edge cases.
Result? One botched automation and boom—200 tickets closed, no agent response, and a Twitter thread of angry customers.
Fix it:
- Add time-based escalations for critical issues.
- Monitor failed automations (e.g., failed webhook calls or action errors).
- Use CSAT triggers to follow up on low scores automatically.
5. Treating Automation as a One-Time Setup
Mistake: Set it and forget it. You build a rule once and never look back.
Result? Your business evolves, but your automation stays stuck in 2022 logic.
Fix it:
- Review automation rules quarterly.
- Use audit logs and reporting features to track automation performance.
- Get feedback from agents about what’s working and what’s not.
Bonus Tip: Use Marketplace Apps to Supercharge Automation
Apps like:
- Auto Close (schedule when tickets are closed)
- Future Ticket (create tickets in the future for follow-ups)
- Schedule Send (send emails at optimal times)
- HubSpot CRM Plus (sync contact info seamlessly)
can reduce manual effort and make your automation actually helpful.
Final Thoughts
Helpdesk automation isn’t about replacing humans—it’s about freeing them up to do what they do best: solving problems and building relationships.
Done right, automation will enhance your CX and boost agent happiness.
Done wrong? Well... we’ll be here with coffee and debugging tips.
If you're looking to get your automation right the first time, Saasly's custom Freshdesk apps might just be your new best friend.
Need help? Reach out to us. We’ve seen it all (and fixed most of it).